[CentOS-devel] 5.3´s anaconda src.rpm missing
james at fedoraproject.org
Thu Apr 9 14:47:19 UTC 2009
On Thu, 2009-04-09 at 10:21 -0400, Lamar Owen wrote:
> On Wednesday 08 April 2009 17:36:18 R P Herrold wrote:
> > I would be thrilled to have a simultaneous coordinated
> > release, but the 'leak' of 'patched' torrent instances, and at
> > least two mirrors opening the full ISO set before the
> > coordinated bit flip date and time, leave rather a bad outlook
> > to me as to the ability to make things better through such an
> > 'inverted as to demand' approach
> > My $0.02 .... I'd love to be shown a path to avoid the
> > problems on the 5.3 roll-out
> Russ, Karnbir, et al:
> Now, as to the technical issues, it seems to me that a fully ACID compliant
> transactional repository mirror system is possibly one way to eliminate most
> of these issues. Such a system to my knowledge does not yet exist;
If you want to have a technical talk, you probably want to speak to
Matt Domsch who does the mirroring for Fedora (releases 2x a year and
As of "recent" versions of yum, creating repos. with
--unique-md-filenames means an atomic move from a fully working old DB
to a new one can¹ be done with rename("new-repomd.xml", "repomd.xml").
Which, excepting ext4 ;), is pretty atomic. However my understanding,
from speaking to Matt, is that "release day" problems are almost
entirely due to getting that very last change to all the mirrors in a
Also metalink data can be used to automatically filter out mirrors with
However those both require some sacrifices for people using the GA
version of yum in CentOS-5, so I'm doubtful that's it's worth the pain.
> But the current pull updating structure doesn't lend itself
> readily to this.
Trying not to speak too much for Matt, but my understanding is that
almost no external mirrors will accept pull mirroring.
¹ My understanding is that no mirrors both with this level of atomic
update, but it's possible.
James Antill - james at fedoraproject.org
"I'd just like to see a realistic approach to updates via
packages." -- Les Mikesell
More information about the CentOS-devel