I am trying to get my two WAN ethernet connections into one box to work.> Traffic will already route out the appropriate interface for a directly connected network. So packets to an IP on the 74.223.8.176/28 subnet should route out eth1 and packets to the 24.123.23.168/29 network will route out eth2. Are you trying to route other subnets within the 74.X.X.X out eth1?