I would like to confirm Matt's claim. I too experienced larger latencies with Centos 5.x compared to 4.x. My application is very network sensitive and its easy to prove using lat_tcp.
Russ, I am curious about identifying the problem. What tools do you recommend to find where the latency is coming from in the application?
On Fri, May 20, 2011 at 2:46 PM, R P Herrold herrold@owlriver.com wrote:
On Fri, 20 May 2011, Matt Garman wrote:
We have several latency-sensitive "pipeline"-style programs that have a measurable performance degredation when run on CentOS 5.x versus CentOS 4.x.
By "pipeline" program, I mean one that has multiple threads. The mutiple threads work on shared data. Between each thread, there is a queue. So thread A gets data, pushes into Qab, thread B pulls from Qab, does some processing, then pushes into Qbc, thread C pulls from Qbc, etc. The initial data is from the network (generated by a 3rd party).
We basically measure the time from when the data is received to when the last thread performs its task. In our application, we see an increase of anywhere from 20 to 50 microseconds when moving from CentOS 4 to CentOS 5.
Anyone have any experience with this? Perhaps some more areas to investigate?
We do procesing similar to this with financials markets datastreams. You do not say, but I assume you are blocking on a select, rather than polling [polling is bad here]. Also you do not say if all threds are under a common process' ownership. If not, mod complexity of debugging threading, you may want to do so
I say this, because in our testing (both with all housed in a single process, and when using co-processes fed through an anaoymous pipe), we will occasionally get hit with a context or process switch, which messes up the latencies something fierce. An 'at' or 'cron' job firing off can ruin the day as well
Also, system calls are to be avoided, as the timing on when (and if, and in what order) one gets returned to, is not something controllable in userspace
Average latencies are not so meaningful here ... collecton of all dispatch and return data and explaining the outliers is probably a good place to continue with afer addresing the foregoing. graphviz, and gnuplot are lovely for doing this kind of visualization
-- Russ herrold _______________________________________________ CentOS mailing list CentOS@centos.org http://lists.centos.org/mailman/listinfo/centos