[CentOS] quick question on RAID 1

Chris Mauritz chrism at imntv.com
Sat Aug 13 17:11:13 UTC 2005


Ulrik S. Kofod wrote:

>I have 3 disks that I want to setup in a raid 1, my questions is should I setup the
>3rd disk as a spare-disk or should I mirror all 3 disks all the time?
>
>Will it perform *much* better to only mirror two and have the 3rd as a spare.
>Is it not safer to mirror all 3 drives all the time ?
>
>  
>

I really don't understand the question.  RAID-1 requires an even number 
of disks since disk(s) A simply is a mirror image of disk(s) B.  So with 
3 disks you could have a 2-drive mirror and designate the 3rd drive as a 
hot spare.  So if one of your mirrored drives fails, the hot spare takes 
over.  You could just as easily do a 3-disk RAID-5 array.  It would be 
substantially faster on reads than a 2-disk mirror.  It could be faster 
or slower on writes depending on which hardware RAID card you're using 
or how fast your processor is if you're doing software RAID.

Cheers,




More information about the CentOS mailing list