[CentOS] Replacing a hard drive

Wed Mar 14 22:46:24 UTC 2007
John Summerfield <debian at herakles.homelinux.org>

John R Pierce wrote:
> John Summerfield wrote:
>> John R Pierce wrote:
>>>    dump 0f - /mnt/src | (cd /mnt/dst; restore rf - )
>>> ...
>> And presumably, fairly quickly. I've never used dump/restore, but if 
>> it does the obvious and decides which blocks top copy, sorts the list 
>> then copies, it should be quickest of all, regardless of the data 
>> content.
> dump/restore is an exact file by file copy of a filesystem, it 
> replicates the directory entries quite exactly including all supported 
> attributes..   I probably got in the habit of using it from Solaris, 
> which has the rather similar ufsdump/ufsrestore.

I used to use, on OS/VS many years ago, a program called IEHDASDR. It 
does a track-by-track dump of a disk, in track order, of those tracks 
used by files and ignores tracks outside of allocated space. The only 
track requiring special attention is cyl 0, track 0 which contains a 
pointer to the VTOC (directory) which itself is a file.

My ordering the tracks, it all but eliminates seeking.

> another method is
>    cd /source; tar clf - . | (cd /dest; tar xvf -)

That's what I said, more-or-less;-)

> but not all versions of tar have the -l (--one-file-system) option (gnu 
> tar in CentOS does, however).
> oh yeah, dump will dump an unmounted filesytem too, so in fact, that 
> could have been...
>    mount /dev/hda1 /mnt/dst
>    cd /mnt/dst
>    dump 0f - /dev/hdb1 | restore rf -

That supports my suggestion that it might, like IEHDASDR, order the 
block list so as to minimise seeking.

Archive programs such as tar are slow when there's a lot of data, but 
perform relatively well when there's not a lot of files, and doesn't 
copy deleted files. Tar causes lots of seeking.

dd is a straightforward sector-by-sector copy and is faster than tar 
when the disk is relatively full of files, but it copies deleted files 
and any other junk.

I think dump copies the smallest necessary volume of data, in the best 
possible order. Its disadvantage is that it cannot change from own 
filesystem to another.

There are other dump/restore programs for other filesystems.



-- spambait
1aaaaaaa at coco.merseine.nu  Z1aaaaaaa at coco.merseine.nu

Please do not reply off-list