I have a couple users, in a new install of a samba file server on CentOS 4.2, who are being prompted to overwrite the existing file when in MS-Excel and simply saving the active spreadsheet. Normally, File--Save (or just clicking on the disk icon) for an already saved file will re-save the file without prompting to overwrite.
I have my doubts about whether this could be a server-side issue, and suspect it's probably Excel, except
1) it started when I switched them from a Windows file server to the Samba server; 2) it happened to both of them at the same time; 3) I've been working with Excel for a long time and never seen a setting for this.
Anybody have any idea what this could be, or how to diagnose it? Googling gets me a few VBScript questions, nothing useful.
FYI, the samba share is pretty basic, but I did increase the create mask and directory mask settings, since these files are shared between several users and they need to write each other's files. Apart from that, no deviations from the norm.
Thanks, Matt
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 19:57 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
I have a couple users, in a new install of a samba file server on CentOS 4.2, who are being prompted to overwrite the existing file when in MS-Excel and simply saving the active spreadsheet. Normally, File--Save (or just clicking on the disk icon) for an already saved file will re-save the file without prompting to overwrite.
I have my doubts about whether this could be a server-side issue, and suspect it's probably Excel, except
- it started when I switched them from a Windows file server to the
Samba server; 2) it happened to both of them at the same time; 3) I've been working with Excel for a long time and never seen a setting for this.
Anybody have any idea what this could be, or how to diagnose it? Googling gets me a few VBScript questions, nothing useful.
FYI, the samba share is pretty basic, but I did increase the create mask and directory mask settings, since these files are shared between several users and they need to write each other's files. Apart from that, no deviations from the norm.
---- Excel is very peculiar in how it saves files.
see
http://article.gmane.org/gmane.network.samba.general/60586/match=excel
a lot of fixes were put into Samba-3.0.11 and I would guess that upstream incorporated many of the patches since I've not had complaints about that. Have you installed all updates? # rpm -q samba samba-3.0.10-1.4E.2
Craig
On 1/25/06, Craig White craigwhite@azapple.com wrote:
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 19:57 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
I have a couple users, in a new install of a samba file server on CentOS 4.2, who are being prompted to overwrite the existing file when in MS-Excel and simply saving the active spreadsheet. Normally, File--Save (or just clicking on the disk icon) for an already saved file will re-save the file without prompting to overwrite.
I have my doubts about whether this could be a server-side issue, and suspect it's probably Excel, except
- it started when I switched them from a Windows file server to the
Samba server; 2) it happened to both of them at the same time; 3) I've been working with Excel for a long time and never seen a setting for this.
Anybody have any idea what this could be, or how to diagnose it? Googling gets me a few VBScript questions, nothing useful.
FYI, the samba share is pretty basic, but I did increase the create mask and directory mask settings, since these files are shared between several users and they need to write each other's files. Apart from that, no deviations from the norm.
Excel is very peculiar in how it saves files.
see
http://article.gmane.org/gmane.network.samba.general/60586/match=excel
a lot of fixes were put into Samba-3.0.11 and I would guess that upstream incorporated many of the patches since I've not had complaints about that. Have you installed all updates? # rpm -q samba samba-3.0.10-1.4E.2
Yes, that's the version I'm running.
So I looked into this a lot more and realized there's a lot more to file-locking, etc., than I realized. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction. My other samba server (also CentOS 4.2, also samba 3.0.10-14E2) only deals with Excel 97 and OOo clients, and it looks like 2000/2003 create problems that 97 doesn't.
Anyway, I checked around, and I'm getting totally conflicting opinions on whether to turn oplocks and level2 oplocks on or off. Can I get opinions from the list? This particular business does not do a lot of MS-Access (which offers good reasons to have oplocks turned on).
Thanks, Matt
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 21:51 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
On 1/25/06, Craig White craigwhite@azapple.com wrote:
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 19:57 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
I have a couple users, in a new install of a samba file server on CentOS 4.2, who are being prompted to overwrite the existing file when in MS-Excel and simply saving the active spreadsheet. Normally, File--Save (or just clicking on the disk icon) for an already saved file will re-save the file without prompting to overwrite.
I have my doubts about whether this could be a server-side issue, and suspect it's probably Excel, except
- it started when I switched them from a Windows file server to the
Samba server; 2) it happened to both of them at the same time; 3) I've been working with Excel for a long time and never seen a setting for this.
Anybody have any idea what this could be, or how to diagnose it? Googling gets me a few VBScript questions, nothing useful.
FYI, the samba share is pretty basic, but I did increase the create mask and directory mask settings, since these files are shared between several users and they need to write each other's files. Apart from that, no deviations from the norm.
Excel is very peculiar in how it saves files.
see
http://article.gmane.org/gmane.network.samba.general/60586/match=excel
a lot of fixes were put into Samba-3.0.11 and I would guess that upstream incorporated many of the patches since I've not had complaints about that. Have you installed all updates? # rpm -q samba samba-3.0.10-1.4E.2
Yes, that's the version I'm running.
So I looked into this a lot more and realized there's a lot more to file-locking, etc., than I realized. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction. My other samba server (also CentOS 4.2, also samba 3.0.10-14E2) only deals with Excel 97 and OOo clients, and it looks like 2000/2003 create problems that 97 doesn't.
Anyway, I checked around, and I'm getting totally conflicting opinions on whether to turn oplocks and level2 oplocks on or off. Can I get opinions from the list? This particular business does not do a lot of MS-Access (which offers good reasons to have oplocks turned on).
---- I always create a share just for db's and have oplocks completely off on that share but leave my other shares alone.
Craig
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 21:51 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
On 1/25/06, Craig White craigwhite@azapple.com wrote:
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 19:57 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
I have a couple users, in a new install of a samba file server on CentOS 4.2, who are being prompted to overwrite the existing file when in MS-Excel and simply saving the active spreadsheet. Normally, File--Save (or just clicking on the disk icon) for an already saved file will re-save the file without prompting to overwrite.
I have my doubts about whether this could be a server-side issue, and suspect it's probably Excel, except
- it started when I switched them from a Windows file server to the
Samba server; 2) it happened to both of them at the same time; 3) I've been working with Excel for a long time and never seen a setting for this.
Anybody have any idea what this could be, or how to diagnose it? Googling gets me a few VBScript questions, nothing useful.
FYI, the samba share is pretty basic, but I did increase the create mask and directory mask settings, since these files are shared between several users and they need to write each other's files. Apart from that, no deviations from the norm.
Excel is very peculiar in how it saves files.
see
http://article.gmane.org/gmane.network.samba.general/60586/match=excel
a lot of fixes were put into Samba-3.0.11 and I would guess that upstream incorporated many of the patches since I've not had complaints about that. Have you installed all updates? # rpm -q samba samba-3.0.10-1.4E.2
Yes, that's the version I'm running.
So I looked into this a lot more and realized there's a lot more to file-locking, etc., than I realized. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction. My other samba server (also CentOS 4.2, also samba 3.0.10-14E2) only deals with Excel 97 and OOo clients, and it looks like 2000/2003 create problems that 97 doesn't.
---- btw - bugzilla upstream has this entry... https://bugzilla.redhat.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=171897
which references a fix from Microsoft (install OfficeXP - Service Pack 3) http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-us;324491
Craig
On 1/25/06, Craig White craigwhite@azapple.com wrote:
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 21:51 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
On 1/25/06, Craig White craigwhite@azapple.com wrote:
On Wed, 2006-01-25 at 19:57 -0500, Matt Morgan wrote:
I have a couple users, in a new install of a samba file server on CentOS 4.2, who are being prompted to overwrite the existing file when in MS-Excel and simply saving the active spreadsheet. Normally, File--Save (or just clicking on the disk icon) for an already saved file will re-save the file without prompting to overwrite.
I have my doubts about whether this could be a server-side issue, and suspect it's probably Excel, except
- it started when I switched them from a Windows file server to the
Samba server; 2) it happened to both of them at the same time; 3) I've been working with Excel for a long time and never seen a setting for this.
Anybody have any idea what this could be, or how to diagnose it? Googling gets me a few VBScript questions, nothing useful.
FYI, the samba share is pretty basic, but I did increase the create mask and directory mask settings, since these files are shared between several users and they need to write each other's files. Apart from that, no deviations from the norm.
Excel is very peculiar in how it saves files.
see
http://article.gmane.org/gmane.network.samba.general/60586/match=excel
a lot of fixes were put into Samba-3.0.11 and I would guess that upstream incorporated many of the patches since I've not had complaints about that. Have you installed all updates? # rpm -q samba samba-3.0.10-1.4E.2
Yes, that's the version I'm running.
So I looked into this a lot more and realized there's a lot more to file-locking, etc., than I realized. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction. My other samba server (also CentOS 4.2, also samba 3.0.10-14E2) only deals with Excel 97 and OOo clients, and it looks like 2000/2003 create problems that 97 doesn't.
btw - bugzilla upstream has this entry... https://bugzilla.redhat.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=171897
which references a fix from Microsoft (install OfficeXP - Service Pack 3) http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-us;324491
Craig
Craig, thanks for finding that for me! That sure looks like it will help.
-
Craig White -
Matt Morgan