[CentOS-devel] forums + portal for {lang}.centos.org sites

Thu Sep 25 20:47:38 UTC 2008
Ned Slider <ned at unixmail.co.uk>

Marcus Moeller wrote:
> Dear Ned.
>>>> http://www.simplemachines.org/about/license.php
> ...
>>> I don't like the license :)
>> I don't like it either - that's why I raised it. Is it a show stopper
>> discounting SMF from further consideration or is it something we can still
>> work with (the license) and keep it on the shortlist? No point doing a lot
>> of ldap integration work or whatever to only find out down the line the
>> license isn't tolerable.
> I agree. This license makes it nealy impossible to use/distribute it.

I don't really see any restrictions on it's use, only it's distribution. 
   I just don't particularly like the language per se.

>>>>> - Must address the specific requirements raised by the present
>>>>>  www.centos.org forum users ( Can you please fill this section in ? )
>>>> This is a task I can do. Where/how would you like the information?
>>> Why not here in this thread first?
>> Here is a summary of issues raised by forum users so far:
>> *Major*
>> - Persistent logins (users currently have to re-login every 24h)
>> - The remember me, keep cookie for 1 year option looks broken (relates to
>> point 1 above and is presumably a xoops issue)
>> - View/jump to first unread post within thread feature
>> - Remember read/unread posts across multiple PCs/logins (per user, not per
>> machine)
>> - Ability for users to change/edit their registered email address.
>> - Better management of subscribed threads
>> *Minor*
>> - Thank User button/feature
>> - Quick links feature
> I think phpBB addresses nearly all of these issues. It scales well and
> is GPL licensed. It also inculdes an easy update/patch management
> system which is really necessary in my pov.

Can you (or anyone) point me to any good examples of phpBB forum 
deployments where I could register to get a feel for it's end-user 
features/usability? (I'm already familiar with some SMF based forums and 
it certainly meets end user requirements).