On 12/1/22 07:30, Alex Iribarren wrote: > Hi Johnny, > > On 12/1/22 02:12, Johnny Hughes wrote: >> We are working on moving the CentOS Stream 8 process to be like the >> CentOS Stream 9 process. Once that process is in place it will help >> prevent issues like this. But this takes time. >> >> The main reason these things can happen right now is the standard >> repoclosure does not work properly with modules integrated into the >> distribution. >> >> We rolled in t_functional tests that catch many of these issues, like >> this test: >> >> https://github.com/CentOS/sig-core-t_functional/blob/master/tests/0_common/50_test_comps.sh >> >> That tests comps install groups. >> >> When new items come up, we try to add tests to prevent them in the >> future. >> >> We are now working on a specific t_functional test to check the Samba, >> IPA, SSSD, evolution-mapi, openchange chain. >> >> Community pull requests for t_fucntional gladly accepted :) > > Thanks for highlighting 50_test_comps.sh. In fact, I contributed that > test myself exactly to catch these sorts of issues. I suppose it didn't > catch it in this case, but I can't actually confirm because > ci.centos.org seems to be down. Maybe it was down when these packages > were being built and that compose didn't go through the CI? > > My open issue with the CentOS Board is precisely to have something like > ci.centos.org and t_functional for Stream 9, which is something that > doesn't currently exist. We run tests CI tests for 'el7' and 'c8s' in our QA CI setup right now. That test did run and pass. It seems it does not test the right combinations of packages for that chain together in an install (samba/ipa/openchange/evolution-mapi/sssd). Which is why we are writing a specific test for this specific chain. We am also working on a test to ensure we don't forget to rebuild annobin if we upgrade gcc. I know that as a group we are working on getting t_functional working for CentOS Stream 9 (you can see that from the many updates by Adam Selah in there lately). https://github.com/CentOS/sig-core-t_functional/commits/master My understanding is that this will be run on CentOS Stream 9 composes (and CentOS Stream 8 composes once the builds move to the new koji stream builder) in a different location that publicly available, before release. You can also see the builds from the current c8s builder are being moved to the new koji stream builder (right now actually): https://kojihub.stream.centos.org/koji/builds Everything 'el8' in there is me moving things over. So this is being actively worked on. Thanks, Johnny Hughes